Dharmic faiths: While the Abrahamic religions
prohibit cremation or prefer burial over
cremation, the Eastern religions (i.e.,
Dharmic faiths) such as Hinduism and
Buddhism mandate the use of cremation. In
these religions the body is seen as an
instrument to carry the soul in that
birth. As an example the Bhagavad Gita
quotes "Just as old clothes are cast
off and new ones taken, the soul leaves
the body after the death to take a new
one". Hence the dead body is not
considered sacred since the soul has left
the body. Hence, the cremation is regarded
as ethical by the Eastern religions. In
Sikhism, burial is not prohibited,
although cremation is the preferred option
for cultural reasons rather than
religious.
According
to Hindu traditions, the reasons for
preference of destroying the corpse by
fire over burying it into ground, is to
induce a feeling of detachment into the
freshly-disembodied spirit, which will be
helpful to encourage it into passing to
'the other world' (the ultimate
destination of the dead). This also
explains the ground-burial of holy men
(whose spirit is already 'detached' enough
due to lifelong ascetic practices) and
young children (the spirit has not lived
long enough to grow attachments to this
world). Hindu holy men are buried in lotus
position and not in horizontal position as
in other religions. Cremation is referred
to as antim-samskara, literally
meaning "the last rites". At the
time of the cremation or "last
rites" a "Puja" is
performed. A "Puja" is a Hindu
prayer to assist the spirit to transcend
into the after life.
Christianity
In
Christian countries, cremation fell out of
favour with the people. The Catholic
Church's discouragement of cremation
stemmed from several ideas: first, that
the body, as the instrument through which
the sacraments are received, is itself a
sacramental, a holy object; second that as
an integral part of the human person, it
should be disposed of in a way that honors
and reverences it, and many early
practices involved with disposal of dead
bodies were viewed as pagan in origin or
an insult to the body; third, that in imitation of Jesus Christ's burial, the body of
a Christian should be buried; and fourth,
that it constituted a denial of the
resurrection of the body. Cremation was
not forbidden because it might interfere
with God's ability to resurrect the
body, however; this was refuted as early
as Minucius Felix, in his dialogue Octavius.
Cremation
was, in fact, not forbidden in and of
itself; even in Medieval Europe cremation
was practised in situations where there
were multitudes of corpses simultaneously
present, such as after a battle, after a
pestilence or famine, and where there was
an imminent danger of diseases spreading
from the corpses. However,
earth burial or entombment remained the
law unless there were circumstances that
required cremation for the public good
.Beginning in the Middle Ages, and even
more so in the 18th Century and later,
rationalists and classicists began to
advocate cremation again as a statement
denying the resurrection and/or the
afterlife,although the pro-cremation
movement more often than not took care to
address and refute theological concerns
about cremation in their works. Sentiment
within the Catholic Church against
cremation became hardened in the face of
the association of cremation with
"professed enemies of God".
Rules were made against cremation, which
were softened in the 1960s. The Catholic
Church still officially prefers the
traditional burial or entombment of the
deceased, but cremation is now freely
permitted as long as it is not done to
express a refusal to believe in the
resurrection of the body.
Until
1997, Catholic liturgical regulations
required that cremation take place after
the funeral Mass, so that, if possible,
the body might be present for the Mass -
the body was present as a symbol, and to
receive the blessings and be the subject
of prayers in which it is mentioned. Once
the Mass itself was concluded, the body
could be cremated and a second service
could be held at the crematorium or
cemetery where the ashes were to be
interred just as for a body burial. The
liturgical regulations now allow for a
Mass with the container of ashes present,
but permission of the local bishop is
needed for this. The Church still
specifies requirements for the reverent
disposition of ashes, normally that the
ashes are to be buried or entombed in an
appropriate container, such as an urn
(rather than scattered or preserved in the
family home, although there are Catholics
who do this anyway). Catholic cemeteries
today regularly receive cremated remains
and many have columbaria.
Protestant
churches were much more welcoming of the
use of cremation and at a much earlier
date than the Catholic Church;
pro-cremation sentiment was not unanimous
among Protestants, however. The
first crematoria in the Protestant
countries were built in 1870s, and in 1908
the Dean and Chapter of Westminster Abbey,
one of the most famous Anglican churches,
required that remains be cremated for
burial in the abbey's precincts.
Scattering, or "strewing," is an
acceptable practice in many Protestant
denominations, and some churches have
their own "garden of
remembrance" on their grounds in
which remains can be scattered. Other
Christian groups also support cremation.
These include the Jehovah's Witnesses.
On
the other hand, some branches of
Christianity still oppose cremation,
including some minority Protestant groups.
Most notably, the Eastern Orthodox
Churches forbid cremation. Exceptions are
made for circumstances where it may not be
avoided (when civil authority demands it,
or epidemics) or if it may be sought for
good cause, but when a cremation is
willfully chosen for no good cause by the
one who is deceased, he or she is not
permitted a funeral in the church and may
also be permanently excluded from
liturgical prayers for the departed. In
Orthodoxy, cremation is a rejection of the
dogma of the general resurrection, and as
such is viewed harshly.
Judaism
Judaism
has traditionally disapproved of cremation
(which was the traditional means of
disposing the dead in the neighboring
Bronze Age cultures). Traditionally, it
has also disapproved of preservation of
the dead by means of embalming and
mummifying, a practice of the
ancient Egyptians. During the 19th and
early 20th centuries, as the Jewish
cemeteries in many European towns had
become crowded and were running out of
space, cremation became an approved means
of corpse disposal amongst the Liberal
Jews. Current liberal movements like
Reform Judaism still support cremation,
although burial remains the preferred
option.
The
Orthodox Jews have maintained a stricter
line on cremation, and disapprove of it as
Halakha (Jewish law) forbids it. This
halakhic concern is grounded in the
upholding of bodily resurrection as a core
belief of "mainstream" Judaism,
as opposed to other ancient trends such as
the Sadduccees, who denied it. Also, the
memory of the Holocaust, where millions of
Jews were murdered and their bodies
disposed by burning them either in
crematoria or burning pits, has given
cremation extremely negative connotations
for Orthodox Jews. Conservative Jewish
groups also oppose cremation.
Mormonism
Since
the organization of the Church in 1830,
Latter-day Saints have been encouraged by
their leaders to avoid cremation, unless
it is required by law, and, wherever
possible, to consign the body to burial in
the earth and leave the dissolution of the
body to nature, "for dust thou art,
and unto dust shalt thou return"
(Gen. 3:19). President Spencer W. Kimball
wrote, "The meaning of death has not
changed. It releases a spirit for growth
and development and places a body
in…Mother Earth" (p. 45). In due
time the mortal body returns to native
element, and whether it is laid away in a
family-selected site or buried in the
depths of the sea, every essential part
will be restored in the Resurrection:
"Every limb and joint shall be
restored to its body; yea, even a hair of
the head shall not be lost; but all things
shall be restored to their proper and
perfect frame" (Alma 40:23).
To
understand the LDS feeling about
cremation, it is essential to understand
the doctrine of the Church regarding the
body. In a General Conference Elder James
E. Talmage, an apostle, stated, "It
is peculiar to the theology of the
Latter-day Saints that we regard the body
as an essential part of the soul. Read
your dictionaries, the lexicons, and
encyclopedias, and you will find that
nowhere, outside of The Church of Jesus
Christ, is the solemn and eternal truth
taught that the soul of man is the body
and the spirit combined" (CR, Oct.
1913, p. 117).
Zoroastrianism
As
a rule, the Parsis strongly forbid
cremation, as it defiles the fire, symbol
of all that is sacred. Burial is also
disavowed, for similar reasons, and the
traditional method of corpse disposal is
the exposing of the bodies to vultures in
"Towers of silence". However,
some contemporary figures of the faith
have opted for cremation. The former Queen
lead singer, Freddie Mercury, who was a
Parsi-Zoroastrian, was cremated after his
death. In addition, Rajiv Gandhi received
a well-publicized cremation with full
Hindu Vedic rites, on a sandalwood pyre,
though he had a Parsi father.
Neo-Paganisim
According
to Feminist interpretations of the
archaeological record, cremation is the
usual means of corpse disposal in
Patriarchal religions, the rising smoke
symbolizing the deceased's spirit
ascending to the domain of the Father
deities in the heavens, while Matriarchal
religions are speculated to have favoured
interment of the corpse, often in a fetal
position, representing the return of the
body to Mother Earth in the tomb which
represents the uterus. Of modern Neo-Pagan
religions, Ásatrú favours cremation, as
do forms of Celtic Paganism.
Other
religions that permit cremation
Ásatrú,
Buddhism, Christianity (containing Church
of Ireland, Church in Wales, United Church
of Canada, Lutheranism, Methodism,
Moravian Church, Salvation Army, Scottish
Episcopal Church), Christian Science,
Church of Scientology, Hinduism (mandatory
except for sanyasis, eunuchs and children
under five), Jainism, Seventh-day
Adventist Church, Sikhs, Society of
Friends (Quakers), and Unitarian
Universalism all permit cremation.